Is a more efficient appliance worth it? Working out savings and payback
Work out the yearly energy of both appliances on the same basis, multiply the difference by your price per kWh to get the yearly saving, then compare that saving with what the new appliance costs. Simple payback is the cost divided by the yearly saving; it is a starting point, not the whole answer.
Published
Step 1: put both appliances on the same basis
A fair comparison needs the yearly energy of each appliance, worked out the same way and for the same use.
The appliance you have
For an appliance that has been in use for years, a measurement is better than its original label. The label described a new appliance in a standard test; seals, settings and the way you use it may all be different now. A plug-in electricity monitor gives the kWh over a known period, which you can scale to a year. For example, a measured 84 kWh over 28 days is 84 ÷ 28 = 3 kWh a day, or 3 × 365 = 1,095 kWh a year. That 84 kWh is a made-up figure for the arithmetic. Measure for long enough to be representative, and remember that fridges and air conditioners use more in warm weather. How to measure real appliance electricity use explains the methods.
The appliance you are considering
Use the energy label, converted to your use. A fridge label gives kWh per year, which you can use as it is. A washing machine label in the EU gives kWh per 100 cycles of its eco 40-60 program, so multiply by your cycles: at 200 cycles a year, a label figure of 60 kWh per 100 cycles becomes 60 × 200 ÷ 100 = 120 kWh a year. If the old appliance's figure is a measurement and the new one's is a label, the comparison is approximate; the guide to energy labels explains what each label measures.
Step 2: the yearly saving
Yearly energy saving (kWh) = old yearly kWh − new yearly kWh. Yearly cost saving = energy saving × your price per kWh. Use the price you pay for each extra kWh, not the whole bill divided by the kWh; see how to find your electricity price per kWh.
| Existing fridge | New fridge | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy per year | 600 kWh | 350 kWh |
| Cost per year | $120.00 | $70.00 |
| Purchase price | Already owned | $900 |
600 − 350 = 250 kWh a year saved, worth 250 × 0.20 = $50.00 a year, which is also $120.00 − $70.00. All of these figures are invented for the example; they are not typical for any fridge.
The same steps work for other appliances, and they show why the answer differs so much between them. Using the washing machine figures above, a new model labelled 50 kWh per 100 cycles instead of 60, at 200 cycles a year, saves (60 − 50) × 200 ÷ 100 = 20 kWh a year, which is 20 × 0.20 = $4.00. An appliance that runs all day, or uses a lot per use, has more to save.
Step 3: simple payback
Choosing between two new models
If you are buying anyway, only the extra price of the more efficient model needs to be paid back. Simple payback (years) = extra purchase price ÷ yearly cost saving.
| Model A | Model B | |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $600 | $750 |
| Running cost per year | $90.00 | $60.00 |
Model B costs $750 − $600 = $150 more and saves $90.00 − $60.00 = $30.00 a year, so it pays back the difference in 150 ÷ 30 = 5 years. If you expect to keep it longer than that, the extra cost is likely to be repaid, other things being equal.
Replacing an appliance that still works
Here the whole price of the new appliance is the cost, plus any delivery, installation or disposal charge, because you would otherwise spend nothing. With the fridge figures above, $900 ÷ $50.00 = 18 years. If the old fridge would have kept going for another five years, replacing it now for the electricity saving alone does not pay for itself: five years of savings come to 5 × $50.00 = $250.00, against $900. If it is likely to fail soon, you will be buying a new one anyway, and the two-model comparison above is the better guide.
The price matters as much as the appliance. At an illustrative $0.30 per kWh, the same 250 kWh saving is worth 250 × 0.30 = $75.00 a year and the payback falls to 900 ÷ 75 = 12 years.
What simple payback leaves out
- Future prices. It assumes today's price for every year. If prices rise, the saving grows; if they fall, it shrinks.
- How long each appliance will last. A payback longer than the new appliance's life never arrives, and the remaining life of the old appliance is part of the decision.
- Other costs. Delivery, installation, disposal, maintenance and repairs are not in the formula unless you add them.
- The value of money over time. A dollar saved in ten years is worth less to you than a dollar spent today. Simple payback treats them as equal.
- How you use the appliance. The FTC notes that the EnergyGuide cost figure is only an estimate, based on typical use and a national average price; your own cost depends on how you use the appliance and your local price.
Lifetime cost: a fuller comparison
Lifetime cost adds the running cost over the years you expect to keep an appliance to its price: lifetime cost = purchase price + yearly running cost × years. It still assumes a constant price and leaves out repairs and the value of money over time, but it compares the two options over the same period.
| Appliance A | Appliance B | |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $500 | $700 |
| Running cost per year | $100.00 | $60.00 |
| Running cost over 10 years | $1,000.00 | $600.00 |
| Lifetime cost | $1,500.00 | $1,300.00 |
$500 + $100.00 × 10 = $1,500.00 and $700 + $60.00 × 10 = $1,300.00. Appliance B costs $200 more to buy but $200 less over ten years. Over five years, the totals would be $1,000.00 and $1,000.00, so the period you choose matters.
Getting the yearly costs
Enter each appliance in the appliance cost calculator with the same price: the old one with your measured kWh, the new one with its label figure. Add both to the comparison list to see their yearly costs side by side, then use the difference in the formulas above. How to compare appliance running costs explains how to keep a comparison like this fair.
Related guides
- How to compare the running costs of different appliances
- How to read appliance energy labels
- How to measure real appliance electricity use
- All guides
Sources
These sources support specific statements on this page. They do not review or endorse this calculator or its results. Last reviewed .
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission: How to use the EnergyGuide label to shop for home appliances. Explains that the EnergyGuide operating cost is only an estimate based on typical use and a national average energy price, that your cost depends on how you use the appliance and your local price, and that the label lets you compare similar models.
- European Commission: Fridges and freezers. EU fridge and freezer labels give the annual energy consumption in kWh.
- European Commission: Washing machines. EU washing machine labels give the weighted energy consumption per 100 cycles of the eco 40-60 program.
How this guide was written
The first draft was written with the help of an AI writing assistant. It was then edited, every calculation was worked through again, and each factual statement was checked against the sources listed above; statements that could not be checked were removed. Example figures are illustrations chosen to show the arithmetic, not measurements or typical values. See the methodology for how the calculators work.