Appliance EnergyCost Calculator

Fan, oil-filled, convector or infrared: does the heater type change electricity use?

Not for the same power and time. Fan, oil-filled, convector and infrared heaters that heat with an electric element turn the electricity they use into heat, so two heaters drawing the same watts for the same hours use the same kWh. The type changes how the heat reaches you, which can change how long you choose to run it.

Published

Why the type does not change the kWh

Most portable electric heaters, whatever they look like, work the same way: electricity flows through a heating element and its resistance turns that electricity into heat. Natural Resources Canada puts it simply: electric space heaters produce one unit of heat for every unit of electricity, which makes them 100 percent efficient at the point of use. The same body adds that this does not make them the most efficient heating choice overall; heat pumps, below, can do better.

So the electricity a resistance heater uses depends on two things: the power it draws and how long it draws it. A fan heater and an oil-filled radiator that both draw 1,500 W for two hours use the same 1,500 × 2 ÷ 1,000 = 3 kWh. At the same power, a difference in running cost between two heaters comes from how long, and at what setting, each one runs, not from the electricity it uses per hour.

How each type delivers heat

Natural Resources Canada groups electric space heaters as fan-forced, convection and radiant. The differences matter for comfort, and comfort decides how long a heater stays on.

  • Fan heaters blow air over the element. You feel warm air quickly, and the heat stops soon after the heater does. The small fan motor is part of the heater's total input power.
  • Convector heaters warm the air, which rises and circulates around the room without a fan. They suit warming a whole room gradually.
  • Oil-filled radiators heat oil sealed inside the fins, which warms the metal and then the room. They take a while to warm up and keep giving off heat for a while after the element switches off. That stored heat is electricity used earlier, released later; it is not extra heat for free.
  • Infrared (radiant) heaters warm people and surfaces in front of them directly, rather than heating the air first. If you only need to be warm in one chair, that can mean running a heater for less time, or at a lower setting, than heating the whole room would need.

These are reasons a type might suit a situation better. None of them changes the arithmetic: at the same power, each heater uses the same energy per hour it is drawing that power.

Power settings and thermostats

Many heaters have more than one power setting, so check which one the rating refers to. On an illustrative heater with 1,000 W and 2,000 W settings, an hour on the low setting uses 1,000 × 1 ÷ 1,000 = 1 kWh and an hour on high uses 2 kWh.

A thermostat changes the picture again. It switches the element off once the room reaches the set temperature and back on as it cools, and Natural Resources Canada notes that thermostats control temperature and therefore energy use. If a 2,000 W element runs for 30 minutes in an hour, that hour uses 2,000 × 0.5 ÷ 1,000 = 1 kWh rather than 2 kWh. How much of the time it runs depends on the room, the insulation, the weather outside and the setting, so the only way to know is to measure. See rated power vs actual electricity use for the method.

Full power: the cost if it never cycles off

If you assume the heater draws its full rated power the whole time it is on, you get the cost of that schedule without any thermostat cycling. The table uses an illustrative 2,000 W heater and an illustrative price of $0.20 per kWh; neither is typical, so use your own heater's rating and your own price.

Illustrative 2,000 W heater at full power, $0.20 per kWh
UseHoursEnergyCost
One hour12 kWh$0.40
One night816 kWh$3.20
24 hours2448 kWh$9.60
Every night for an average month243.33486.67 kWh$97.33
Every night for a year2,9205,840 kWh$1,168.00

The working: 2,000 × 1 ÷ 1,000 = 2 kWh, and 2 × 0.20 = $0.40. A night is 2 × 8 = 16 kWh, costing $3.20, and a full day is 2 × 24 = 48 kWh, costing $9.60. Every night for a year is 16 × 365 = 5,840 kWh, costing $1,168.00, and an average month, a twelfth of that, is 486.67 kWh, costing $97.33. A heater whose thermostat cycles it off uses less than these figures; one that never reaches its set temperature, for example in a cold, draughty room, can use all of it.

Heat pumps are a different category

A heat pump does not make heat from electricity in the same way. It uses electricity to move heat that already exists, from the outdoor air, the ground or water, into the home. Natural Resources Canada explains that the electricity is used to transfer thermal energy between two places, and measures performance with the coefficient of performance (COP): the heat delivered divided by the electricity used. The U.S. Department of Energy's Energy Saver Guide says heat pumps can provide up to three times more heat than the energy they use, and can reduce the electricity used for heating by about 50% compared with electric furnaces or baseboard heaters.

That is why a heat pump cannot be compared with a portable heater by rated watts alone: the Department of Energy says the same electricity can deliver up to three times as much heat. Performance also changes with the outdoor temperature and the installation.

Estimating your own heater

  1. Find the electrical input in watts on the rating plate or in the manual, and note which setting you use.
  2. Enter it with your hours of use in the space heater cost calculator, which shows the cost per hour, overnight, for 24 hours and per month.
  3. Enter your own price per kWh; if your price changes at night, use the price for the hours the heater runs.
  4. Remember the result assumes full power for every hour you entered. For a thermostat-controlled heater, measure instead: a plug-in electricity monitor rated for the heater's current records the kWh it actually used over an evening or a night, which you can multiply by your price.

Always follow the safety instructions in your heater's manual, including where to place it and how to plug it in.

Related guides

Sources

These sources support specific statements on this page. They do not review or endorse this calculator or its results. Last reviewed .

  • Natural Resources Canada: Electric heaters. States that electric space heaters produce one unit of heat for every unit of electricity, which is 100 percent efficient at the end use, that they come as fan-forced, convection and radiant types, and that thermostats control temperature and therefore energy use; notes that geothermal heat pumps can deliver three units of heat for every unit of electricity.
  • Natural Resources Canada: Heating and cooling with a heat pump. Explains that a heat pump uses electricity to transfer heat between two places, and defines the coefficient of performance (COP).
  • U.S. Department of Energy: Energy Saver Guide (2022, PDF). States that heat pumps provide up to three times more heat than the energy they use and can cut electricity use for heating by about 50% compared with electric furnaces or baseboard heaters.

How this guide was written

The first draft was written with the help of an AI writing assistant. It was then edited, every calculation was worked through again, and each factual statement was checked against the sources listed above; statements that could not be checked were removed. Example figures are illustrations chosen to show the arithmetic, not measurements or typical values. See the methodology for how the calculators work.